| Language | English |
|---|---|
| Num users | 400,000 per month |
| Editors |
|
| Launch date | 2004 (age 22) |
| Current status | Online |
3 Quarks Daily is an online news aggregator and blog that curates commentary, essays, and multimedia from selected periodicals, newspapers, journals, and blogs.[1] The focus is on literature, the arts, politics, current affairs, science, philosophy, gossip—and, as stated on their web site—"anything else we deem inherently fascinating." Each day of the week from Tuesday through Sunday features about a dozen items culled from the World Wide Web. Each Monday is devoted to an online magazine which has essays and other previously unpublished content by editors and guest columnists.[2] The stated aim of 3QD is to offer "a one-stop intellectual surfing experience by culling good stuff from all over and putting it in one place."[3][4]
3 Quarks Daily also awards annual prizes, called "quarks", for exceptional writing in the blogosphere, as well as organizing quarterly online symposia on international issues. The blog commands a significant readership and readers follow it in a variety of ways: through an email subscription and an RSS feed, as well as through social media updates via Twitter[5] and Facebook.[6][7][2]
History
Author, engineer, and philosopher S. Abbas Raza founded 3 Quarks Daily in 2004 to serve as a conduit for content across disciplines for the web-based intellectual everyman.[8][unreliable source?] Unlike similar blogs of the time, such as Arts & Letters Daily and Andrew Sullivan's The Daily Dish, 3QD would explore topics beyond the humanities and feature science content as well as commentary on current events. In fact, Abbas Raza says that Arts & Letters Daily, "was one of the main inspirations for my starting 3 Quarks Daily."[9] The first post was on Saturday, July 31, 2004, and featured the 1904 Constantine Cavafy poem Waiting for the Barbarians.[10]
The new aggregator site grew rapidly, reaching a thousand posts within seven months; by 2014 that number had reached thirty-five thousand.[4] Since then, 3 Quarks Daily has culled content from hundreds of sources, from blogs such as Salon, Science Daily, and The Huffington Post, from major publications such as The New York Times, Nature, and The Guardian, to smaller outlets such as Guernica Magazine, The Awl, and The American Scholar.[11]
The name 3 Quarks Daily comes from the elementary nuclear particles of physics which in turn were named after the word quark which James Joyce had used in Finnegans Wake. The confluence of references to both science and literature in a single word suited the intent of the blog perfectly and the founders also thought that the name would be short and memorable. They named their top three annual prizes the Top Quark (1st), the Strange Quark (2nd), and the Charm Quark (3rd).
The DAG-3QD Peace And Justice Symposia
Since 2012 3 Quarks Daily has teamed up with the Amsterdam-based Dialogue Advisory Group (DAG) to present online dialogues on topics of international peace and justice.[12] Occasionally, as in the 2013 symposium on drones, a book is published.[13] As of October 2015 there have been six such symposia as shown below.
| colspan="2" ; style="background:#C9C0BB" | Peace And Justice Symposia | |
|---|---|
| date | topic |
| February 25, 2014 | What is the Future for Colombia's Rebels? |
| September 16, 2013 | The Elusive Quest for Political Stability in Central Asia and Beyond |
| July 1, 2013 | The Iraq War and Democracy in the Middle East |
| February 25, 2013 | The Vexing Complexities of Drones |
| November 26, 2012 | The Role of Gender in Situations of War and Conflict |
| September 3, 2012 | Evaluating the Responsibility to Protect (R2P) Doctrine |
The Quark Prizes
In 2009, in the interest of encouraging and rewarding good writing in the blogosphere, 3QD announced that it would be awarding annual cash prizes, in Science, Arts & Literature, Politics, and Philosophy for the three best blog posts in each of these four fields. The selection process is as follows: After several weeks during which nominees are submitted by 3QD readers and editors, the four principal editors of 3QD (Abbas Raza, Robin Varghese, Morgan Meis, and Azra Raza) narrow the list down to six articles in each category. A prominent intellectual such as Steven Pinker, Richard Dawkins,[14] or Lewis Lapham[15] is chosen in each of the four areas to select the final winners. The prizes are whimsically named the Top Quark (first prize of $500), the Strange Quark (second prize of $200), and the Charm Quark (third prize of $100). Originally the prize amounts were twice as big. Not every prize is awarded every year, and no prizes at all were awarded in 2013.
Due to logistical and financial reasons, the Quark Prizes were discontinued after 2015. A complete list of prizes awarded between 2009 and 2015 is shown below.[16]
| colspan="3" ; style="background:#FFD300" | Philosophy Prizes | ||
|---|---|---|
| prize | winner | winning work |
| 2015 Philosophy Prizes — judged by John Collins | ||
| 1 | Vidar Halgunset | Slow Corruption |
| 2 | Daniel Silvermint | On How We Talk About Passing |
| 3 | Lisa Herzog | (One of) Effective Altruism’s blind spot(s) |
| 2014 Philosophy Prizes — judged by Huw Price | ||
| 1 | Grace Boey | Is applied ethics applicable enough? Acting and hedging under moral uncertainty |
| 2 | Ryan Simonelli | Nāgārjuna, Nietzsche, and Rorty’s Strange Looping Trick |
| 3 | Marcus Arvan | The Case for Libertarian Compatibilism |
| 2012 Philosophy Prizes — judged by Justin E. H. Smith | ||
| 1 | Wesley Buckwalter | Factive Verbs and Protagonist Projection |
| 2 | Elizabeth Anderson | Recharting the Map of Social and Political Theory: Where is Government? Where is Conservatism? |
| 3 | Thomas Rodham | Democracy is not a truth machine |
| 2011 Philosophy Prizes — judged by Patricia Churchland | ||
| 1 | Terrence Tomkow | Self Defense |
| 2 | John Schwenkler | Has Molyneux's Question Been Answered? |
| 3 | Jussi Suikkanen | Williams, Thick Concepts, and Reasons |
| 2010 Philosophy Prizes — judged by Akeel Bilgrami | ||
| 1 | Justin Erik Halldor Smith | More on Non-Western Philosophy (the Very Idea) |
| 2 | Terrance Tomkow | The Retributive Theory of Property |
| 3 | Brian Leiter | Katsafanas on "Nietzsche's Philosophical Psychology |
| 2009 Philosophy Prizes — judged by Daniel C. Dennett | ||
| 1 | Terrance Tomkow | Blackburn, Truth and other Hot Topics |
| 2 | David Shoemaker | Scanlon on Moral Responsibility and Blame |
| 3 | Gerald Dworkin | Penne For Your Thought |
| colspan="3" ; style="background:#00FFFF | Science Prizes | ||
|---|---|---|
| prize | winner | winning work |
| 2015 Science Prizes — judged by Nick Lane | ||
| 1 | Ashutosh Jogalekar | The fundamental philosophical dilemma of chemistry |
| 2 | Aatish Bhatia | The Sound So Loud That It Circled the Earth Four Times |
| 3 | Nadia Drake | When Hubble Stared at Nothing for 100 Hours |
| 2014 Science Prizes — judged by Frans B. M. de Waal | ||
| 1 | Eric Michael Johnson | Promiscuity Is Pragmatic |
| 2 | Christie Wilcox | Did Allergies Evolve To Save Your Life? |
| 3 | Carl Zimmer | The Wisdom of (Little) Crowds |
| 2012 Science Prizes — judged by Sean M. Carroll | ||
| 1 | Aatish Bhatia | The crayola-fication of the world: How we gave colors names, and it messed with our brains |
| 2 | Cosma Shalizi | In Soviet Union, Optimization Problem Solves You |
| 3 | Holly Dunsworth | Forget bipedalism. What about babyism? |
| 2011 Science Prizes — judged by Lisa Randall | ||
| 1 | Bethany Brookshire | Serotonin and Sexual Preference: Is It Really That Simple? |
| 2 | Anne Jefferson | Levees and the Illusion of Flood Control |
| 3 | Sean M. Carroll | The Fine Structure Constant is Probably Constant |
| 3 | Ethan Siegel | Where Is Everybody? |
| 2010 Science Prizes — judged by Richard Dawkins | ||
| 1 | Ed Yong | Gut bacteria in Japanese people borrowed digesting genes from ocean bacteria |
| 2 | Carl Zimmer | Skullcaps and Genomes |
| 3 | Margaret Morgan | The Evolution of Chloroplasts |
| 2009 Science Prizes — judged by Steven Pinker | ||
| 1 | Adam Lee | Bands of Iron |
| 2 | David Shiffman | The ecological disaster that is dolphin safe tuna |
| 3 | Phil Plait | Ten Things You Don't Know About Hubble |
| colspan="3" ; style="background:#FF55A3" |Arts & Literature Prizes | ||
|---|---|---|
| prize | winner | winning work |
| 2015 Arts & Literature Prizes — judged by Jonathan Kramnick | ||
| 1 | Joanna Walsh | Ventimiglia |
| 2 | David Kurnick | The Essential Gratuitousness of César Aira |
| 3 | Sarah Blackwood | Editing as Carework |
| 2014 Arts & Literature Prizes — judged by Mohsin Hamid | ||
| 1 | Ali Eteraz | The Death of the Urdu Script |
| 2 | Olga Tokarczuk | Everywhere and Nowhere |
| 3 | Matthew Jakubowski | Honest work: an experimental review of an experimental translation |
| 2012 Arts & Literature Prizes — judged by Gish Jen | ||
| 1 | Melissa Fisher | My First Job |
| 2 | Leanne Ogasawara | Leonardo in the Gilded Age |
| 3 | Syed Haider Shahbazd | The Last Novel |
| 2011 Arts & Literature Prizes — judged by Laila Lalami | ||
| 1 | Namit Arora | Joothan: A Dalit's Life |
| 2 | Edan Lepucki | Reading and Race: On Slavery in Fiction |
| 3 | Elliot Colla | The Poetry of Revolt |
| 2010 Arts & Literature Prizes — judged by Robert Pinsky | ||
| 1 | Tomasz Rozycki | Scorched Maps |
| 2 | Amitava Kumar | Postmortem |
| 3 | Lydia Kiesling | Proust's Arabesk: The Museum of Innocence by Orhan |
| colspan="3" ; style="background:#00CC99" |Politics and Social Science Prizes | ||
|---|---|---|
| prize | winner | winning work |
| 2015 Politics and Social Science Prizes — judged by Ken Roth | ||
| 1 | Kenan Malik | Assimilation vs. Multiculturism |
| 2 | Xavier Marquez | The Saudi Monarchy as a Family Firm |
| 3 | Omar Ali | Blasphemy, blasphemy laws, Pakistan, Charlie Hebdo... |
| 2014 Politics and Social Science Prizes — judged by Mark Blyth | ||
| 1 | Kenan Malik | In Defense of Diversity |
| 2 | Filipe Gracio | Democratic Austerity: Semi-sovereign states, semi-sovereign peoples |
| 3 | Philip Cohen | State of Utah falsely claims same-sex marriage ban makes married, man-woman parenting more likely |
| 2011 Politics and Social Science Prizes — judged by Stephen M. Walt | ||
| 1 | Kenan Malik | Rethinking the Idea of "Christian Europe" |
| 2 | David Graeber | On the Invention of Money |
| 3 | Corey Robin | Revolutionaries of the Right: The Deep Roots of Conservative Radicalism |
| 2010 Politics Prizes — judged by Lewis H. Lapham | ||
| 1 | Stephen Walt | Why America is going to regret the Cordoba House controversy |
| 2 | Dan Froomkin | The Two Most Essential, Abhorrent, Intolerable Lies Of George W. Bush's Memoir |
| 3 | Thomas Wells | Politics: Can't Someone Else Do It? |
| 2009 Politics Prizes — judged by Tariq Ali | ||
| 1 | Glenn Greenwald | Greg Craig and Obama's worsening civil liberties record |
| 2 | Glen Ford | The Great Black Hajj of 2009 |
| 3 | Roger Gathman | Republican Virtue and Equality |
Reception
The 3 Quarks Daily blog has been praised by prominent authors and scientists including Richard Dawkins,[17] Christopher Lydon,[18] Steven Pinker,[19] Daniel Dennett,[20] Andrew Sullivan,[21] Ken Roth,[21] Laura Claridge,[20] John Allen Paulos,[20] and Thomas Manuel.[4]
Guest columnists
The Monday magazine is not completely the creation of the 3QD editors; guest columnists are frequently invited.[22] Prominent guest contributors have included:[23][21]
- Marko Ahtisaari
- Arjun Appadurai[24]
- Stephen T. Asma
- Hartosh Singh Bal[25]
- Pranab Bardhan
- Akeel Bilgrami
- Mark Blyth
- Maarten Boudry
- Paul Braterman
- Alexander Cooley
- Gerald Dworkin
- Jennifer Cody Epstein
- Julia Galef
- Mohsin Hamid
- Shadab Zeest Hashmi
- Pervez Hoodbhoy
- Allen M. Hornblum
- Sue Hubbard
- Ahmed Humayun
- Tasneem Zehra Husain
- Sam Kean
- Amitava Kumar
- Laila Lalami
- Kenan Malik
- Suketu Mehta
- Martha Nussbaum
- John Allen Paulos[26]
- Robert Pinsky
- Steven Poole
- Huw Price
- Asad Raza
- Bruce Robbins
- Andy Schmookler
- Andrea Scrima
- Bapsi Sidhwa
- Justin E. H. Smith
- Terese Svoboda
- Robert B. Talisse
- Bilal Tanweer
- Frans De Waal
References
- ^ "Dr. Eric Weiner Publishes 'Representations of Dissent' for 3 Quarks Daily Montclair State University, 11 October 2021
- ^ An Audio Interview with Abbas Raza of 3 Quarks Daily, By Adam Kampe, National Endowment for the Arts Magazine
- ^ "About 3 Quarks Daily". Archived from the original on 2015-10-16. Retrieved 2015-10-28.
- ^ Manuel, Thomas (2016). Why the Web Needs the Little Miracle of 3QuarksDaily The Wire, October 07, 2016
- ^ 3 Quarks Daily on Twitter
- ^ Mohsin Hamid Interview By Kate Murphy, The New York Times: Opinion, March 23, 2013
- ^ 3 Quarks Daily on Facebook
- ^ Boston Review: S. Abbas Raza
- ^ What will be the fate of Arts & Letters Daily? by Carolyn Kellogg, Los Angeles Times, December 28, 2010
- ^ 3QD posting for Saturday, July 31, 2004
- ^ 18 Popular Sites Like Quarksdaily moreofit.com
- ^ "Dialogue Advisory Group: Online Symposia On Peace And Justice". Archived from the original on 2015-09-05. Retrieved 2015-10-28.
- ^ Strawser, Bradley Jay (2014). Opposing Perspectives on the Drone Debate Palgrave Macmillan [2014],
- ^ 3QD Science Blogging Prize By Sean Carroll, Discover Magazine, May 27, 2010
- ^ "Lapham's Quarterly: Lewis Lapham Judges the 3 Quarks Daily Politics Prize". Archived from the original on 2016-03-04. Retrieved 2015-10-28.
- ^ 3QD Philosophy Prize 2009 Finalists
- ^ 3 Quarks Daily announces awards for science blogging ScienceBlogs: May 27, 2009
- ^ Christopher Lydon on Facebook December 6, 2009
- ^ Club Troppo: review of 3 Quarks Daily by Ingolf May 14, 2008
- ^ "ValuesAustralia: 3 Quarks and the Higgs Boson". Archived from the original on 2016-03-04. Retrieved 2015-10-28.
- ^ "3 Quarks Daily: About Us". Archived from the original on 2015-10-16. Retrieved 2015-10-28.
- ^ 3 Quarks Daily Essays Blogs at U Mass Amherst: Hari Balasubramanian
- ^ List of Monday Magazine Contributors
- ^ Arjun Appadurai
- ^ Hartosh Singh Bal
- ^ John Allen Paulos